On the Illusion of Optionality and Infinite Choice

Working draft

Part 2: The road never taken

A path is either worth walking for itself or worth walking for where it ends. Most of my decisions quietly assume both, and the two answers pull against each other.

This is the second of four pieces. The first argued about what is on offer: whether an option that expires is worthless, whether infinite choice is real, whether anyone can achieve anything, and whether regret can guide anything. This one adds two hinges and then follows both readers to their conclusions.

The main points

1. Earning and cashing compete for the same hours

Time spent making gains and time spent enjoying them come out of one account. A twelve-hour day on the business is twelve hours not at the school gate, and the business always asks for one more. If the cashing is never scheduled it does not happen, and the check sits in a drawer.

The other side. Cashing is leakage. Compounding rewards those who never withdraw, and every early withdrawal shrinks the end state. The check is the point; whether I spend it is a separate and lesser question.

2. Delayed gratification that never gratifies is just loss

Deferral is a trade: less now for more later. If later never arrives it was not discipline, only time and value given up for nothing. The virtue is in the collecting, and people who are good at deferring are often bad at stopping.

The other side. Gratification was never the measure. The company exists, the family is secure, the work stands, whether or not its maker enjoyed a day of it. Deferral that produced the outcome succeeded, even if the person who deferred never collected.

The fork

Both readers now face the same fact: whichever path you take, you may fail. What they do with that fact depends on where they stood at each hinge, the four from the first piece and the two above.

Hinge If you accept it If you reject it
Expired options (Part 1) Value exists only when exercised Options earn their keep through the outcome they enable
Infinite choice (Part 1) Your realizable gains are few, so count them Believing in open possibility is how big outcomes get attempted
Achieving anything (Part 1) The tail is real but unlikely, so choose within your range The tail holds most of the value, so aim at it
Regret (Part 1) Every path carries it, so it cannot decide between them It shrinks with the size of the outcome, so maximise that
Earning vs cashing Cashing must be scheduled or it never happens Never withdraw; the end state is what counts
Deferral Gratification that never arrives is loss The outcome stands whether or not you enjoyed it

If you accepted all six: the path has to be worth taking

Value counts only when realized, your time is finite, the far tail is not a plan, and you have cut the other branches. If the path then fails, the one thing you are certain to have collected is the path itself. So it has to pay as you go: the work, the people and the days must be worth having even if the outcome never arrives. Regret will be there either way, so it cannot be the tiebreaker; what the days were like can. A path that is tolerable only as a means is a bet with no floor.

If you rejected all six: the outcome is the right choice, whatever it costs

Value lives in the end state, belief in open possibility is a tool, and withdrawals are leakage. Failure is then just variance, and the answer to variance is to choose the path with the largest outcome and pay what it asks. Choosing for fulfilment along the way means accepting a smaller result in exchange for comfort. The sacrifice is justified by what it buys, and a large enough result is the only answer to the paths not taken.

If you split them

Most people will accept some hinges and reject others. That usually means living by the second conclusion while expecting the rewards of the first: sacrificing everything for an outcome and assuming the trip will also have been enjoyed. The two do not combine. Believing they do is the illusion in the title, the belief that no choice was required.

The questions this leaves me with

What am I deferring, and is there a date on which I collect? If the path I am on failed, would I still be glad to have walked it? If it succeeded, would the result be worth what it cost?

The third piece asks when.