On the Illusion of Optionality and Infinite Choice

Working draft

Part 1: What is on the menu

Keeping my options open feels like prudence. Mostly it is a way of not choosing, and the sense of infinite choice it produces is false: time prices every option, and most expire unexercised.

This is the first of four pieces. It asks what is actually on offer; the second asks what a path is for, the third asks when, and the fourth asks how. Each claim below is a hinge, with the strongest case against it underneath. Which side of each you take decides where the second piece lands.

The main points

1. An option that expires is worthless

Optionality is worth only what I eventually exercise. If I make it the goal, I forbid myself the one act that converts it into anything: committing, which kills the other options. The person with five open doors at forty has paid five premiums and collected no payoff.

The other side. An option does its work while it is held. The fallback job, the second residency, the cash runway are what let me size the main bet aggressively. They pay off through the outcome they made possible, even if never used, and judged by that outcome the premium was well spent.

2. Infinite choice is a lie I tell myself

I can work twelve-hour days to get a business off the ground. I can homeschool my kids and spend more time with them than most parents ever get. I can travel the world and live in a different country every month. Each of these is open to me, and each one done properly takes the whole day. I cannot do all three, and the decade in which each is available is mostly the same decade.

The second illusion hides inside the first: that with enough energy I can do it all. Take it to the extreme and it breaks, because whichever of these I chose, and however well I chose, I could not have done all of them. What one life actually realizes is a short list.

The other side. The illusion is functional. Nobody who priced a startup honestly would start one; the belief that everything remains possible is what gets large things attempted. Accurate accounting of limits produces people who settle early, and settled people do not produce outsized outcomes.

3. I was raised to believe I could achieve anything

Most of us were told this, and it leaves out where we start. People begin at different social ranks, with different money behind them, in different parts of the world. A boy born in Pretoria in 1971 left South Africa as a teenager and, in June 2026, when his rocket company went public, became the world's first trillionaire. So it can happen. It has happened to one person out of eight billion, and even his start is argued over: he calls his childhood lower-middle-income, his father calls it luxury, and neither calls it poverty. Reading that story as proof that the odds are the same for everyone would be unreasonable.

The pattern underneath is a power law. In a power-law distribution there is no typical value: most cases are small, and a very few are enormous, large enough to account for most of the total. Wealth works this way, with a small share of people holding most of it. So do city sizes, book sales and startup returns, where a handful of outcomes outweigh all the rest combined.

Applied here, the extreme outcomes exist and someone will occupy them. But there are very few seats, and advantages compound, so those who start ahead are far more likely to reach them. "Anyone can" is true. "I probably will" is not, and what is realistically on offer to me depends heavily on where I began.

So the decision underneath is which distribution to draw from. In the fat-tailed one most draws lose and a few win enormously. In the ordinary one results cluster around the middle, and I can still land on the wrong side of it. The tail has the higher average, but I get one life, not the average of everyone who took the swing.

The other side. A power law is the best argument for aiming at the tail. When a few outcomes are worth more than all the others together, the average payoff of trying is dominated by the rare win, which is how venture investors reason. The belief that I can achieve anything is the entry ticket to that draw, and discounting myself by my starting point guarantees the result the statistics predicted.

4. Regret is a constant, so it cannot be the guide

At twenty I could have started a family or not, travelled or not, started a business or not. Each choice closed off paths that would have led somewhere different, and there are infinitely many of them. So every life, including the best available one, carries regret for the ones not taken. A cost I pay on every path cannot help me choose between paths, and trying to minimise it is what keeps people holding options.

The other side. Regret is not a constant; it scales with the result. People do not lie awake over the roads not taken when the road they took delivered. A large enough outcome answers the counterfactuals, so the way to minimise regret is to maximise the outcome.

Where this leaves me

If the four claims hold, what is on offer is small: a short list, paid for with everything not on it, and regretted a little whichever way it goes. If they do not hold, what is on offer is as large as I can keep believing it is, and options, belief and a big enough result are the tools for reaching it.

Either way the next question is the same: what the path I pick is for. That is the second piece.

The question this one leaves me with: which options am I holding that I would never actually exercise?

Sources: AP on the first trillionaire ยท the two accounts of his childhood